| Year | Team | Goals |
| 1986 | Durham Courtalds | 131 Goals |
| 1987 | New Durham Wmc | 154 Goals |
| 1988 | Gilesgate Moor Key Windows | 130 Goals |
| 1989 | Hetton Squashtec | 159 Goals |
| 1990 | Carrville Grange Inn | 112 Goals |
| 1991 | Belmont Sportsmans Arms | 94 Goals |
| 1992 | Newton Hall Jovial Monk | 108 Goals |
| 1993 | Sherburn Lambton Arms | 106 Goals |
| 1994 | Bankhead Wanderers | 116 Goals |
| 1995 | Witton Gilbert Glendenning Arms | 121 Goals |
| 1996 | Lumley Snooker Club | 109 Goals |
| 1997 | Coxhoe Red Lion | 123 Goals |
| 1998 | New Brancepeth Wmc | 127 Goals |
| 1999 | Houghton Glendale Social | 141 Goals |
| 2000 | Chilton Wmc | 149 Goals |
| 2001 | Newton Aycliffe Wmc | 127 Goals |
| 2002 | Gilesgate Moor Hotel | 111 Goals |
| 2003 | Hetton Lyons Cricket Club | 99 Goals |
| 2004 | Burnmoor Dun Cow | 93 Goals |
| 2005 | Burnside Wmc | 170 Goals |
| 2005 | Burnside Wmc | 170 Goals |
| 2007 | Pelton Crown Inn | 105 Goals |
| 2008 | Cassop Victoria | 190 Goals |
| 2009 | Washington Usworth Top Club | 186 Goals |
| 2010 | Chester Easystreet Fc | 143 Goals |
| 2011 | New Durham Wmc | 105 Goals |
Durham Trophies Leading League Goalscorers