| Year | Winners | Runners Up |
| 1970 | Wear Valley | Lumley Wmc |
| 1971 | Wear Valley | Bearpark Dog and Gunn |
| 1972 | Esh Winning FC | Philadelphia S.D.O. |
| 1973 | Ludworth B.L. | Metal Bridge Wmc |
| 1974 | Willington Blue Star | Leeholme Wmc |
| 1975 | Middlestone Moor Wmc | Langley Park Rams Head |
| 1976 | Crook Belverdere Wmc | Durham, Boilers |
| 1977 | Durham Boilers | The Hut Wmc FC |
| 1978 | Ushaw Moor Wmc | Crook Belverdere Wmc |
| 1979 | Shiney Travellers Rest | Lumley Warriors Arms |
| 1980 | Ushaw Moor Wmc | Relton Terrace Wmc |
| 1981 | Ferryhill Kings Head | Brandon Wmc |
| 1982 | New Brancepeth Wmc | Sacriston Wmc |
| 1983 | Low Spen Victoria | Lumley Wmc |
| 1984 | Gilesgate Moor D.L.I. | Lumley Wmc |
| 1985 | Crook Old Horse Shoe | Shotton Comrades Wmc |
| 1986 | Gilesgate Moor Lord Gort | Trimdon Village Wmc |
| 1987 | Broompark Loves Hotel | Low Spen Victoria |
| 1988 | Gilesgate Key Windows | Gilesgate Moor D.L.I. |
| 1989 | Hetton Squashtec | Esh Winning Cricket Club |
| 1990 | Trimdon Black Bull | Belmont Travellers Rest |
| 1991 | Silksworth Cavalier | Brancepeth Castle |
| 1992 | Byers Green Wmc | Broompark Loves Hotel |
| 1993 | Chester Bridge Inn | Esh Waterhouses Wmc |
| 1994 | Sherburn Lambton Arms | Sedgefield St Edmunds |
| 1995 | Sherburn Lambton Arms | Newton Hall FC |
| 1996 | Hare and Greyhound | Brandon Bay Horse |
| 1997 | Gilesgate Brittania Inn | Durham Bridge Inn |
| 1998 | Shiney Maidens Walk | Birtley Vigo Inn |
| 1999 | Houghton Glendale Soc | Burnmoor Cricket Club |
| 2000 | Chilton Wmc | Houghton Glendale Soc |
| 2001 | No Ties Took Place due to bad Weather | |
| 2002 | Houghton Glendale Soc | Fatfield North Biddick Inn |
| 2003 | Houghton Glendale Soc | Chilton Wmc |
| 2004 | Chilton Wmc | Gilesgate Moor Hotel |
| 2005 | Houghton Mill All Stars | Washington Dunlop |
| 2006 | Fatfield Albion | Ferryhill Wmc |
| 2007 | Langley Park Wmc | Burnside Wmc |
| 2008 | Biddick Inn | Houghton Mill All stars |
| 2009 | Houghton Mill All Stars | Gilesgate Moor Hotel |
| 2010 | Washington JKS | Gilesgate Moor Hotel |
| 2011 | Langley Park Steelers | Washington Victoria |
The Guards Cup - Sponsored by JB Taxis